Corporate reputation, reputational measurement matrix, reputational risk, kyc, retail. From these, the report identifies the following principal. Events occurred between 1990 and 2004 in companies belonging to the financial sector and that are listed on the major european and us. Pdf operational risk and reputation in the financial. Identifying the specific reputational component, as distinct from the credit, market, or operational risks, will require internal principles for its identification to avoid wanton results or capital overcharges. The paper describes a reputational risk management maturity model. A key finding is that organisations do not identify reputation risk specifically as a risk. The earliest article in our sample modeling and measuring operational risk is by. Reputational effects of operational risk events for financial.
Ibm first risk case studies for financial institutions. Director of internal audit resume samples qwikresume. Reputational effects of operational risk events for. Managing reputation risk why reputation risk is important the office of the comptroller of the currency has identified eight risks that banks need to manage.
Modeling operational risk incorporating reputation risk. One of the greatest challenges faced by the group was the generic definition of operational risk and the need. A practitioners approach reputational risk is the potential that negative publicity regarding an institutions business practices, whether true or not, will cause a decline in the customer base, costly litigation or revenue reductions. Gatzert, modeling operational risk incorporating reputation risk. The book presents arguments that are critical of the basel ii accord, particularly the advanced measurement approach to operational risk. Tested of the companys liquidity scenario to measure the approach to mitigate.
This definition includes legal risk, but excludes strategic risk and reputational risk basel committee, 2006, p. Tax administrations can use this model to gain insight into the maturity of their reputational risk management practices. Measuring operational and reputational risk wiley online books. By examining stock market reactions to the announcement of operational losses by financial companies, this paper attempts to disentangle operational losses from reputational damage. Lets now look at a process that identifies the scope of ethical principles and behaviors most appropriate for building reputational capital. Aldo soprano madrid, spain is group head of operational risk management at unicredit group. Importantly, quantifying stakeholder assessments lends itself to aggregation for an overall perspective on enterpriselevel risk to reputational capital. The appropriate response to a risk impacting reputation will depend on. For example, the conference board 2007 suggests that not. Pdf download measuring operational and reputational risk. Measuring reputation from a risk management perspective, reputational risk remains very dificult to identify in a corporation and almost impossible to quantify. Corporate reputational risk and enterprise risk management.
The earliest article in our sample modeling and measuring operational risk is by cruz et al. By operational risk, i mean primarily the risk of loss from internal control breakdowns. Modelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given situation, according to the type of risk an organization is facing. It is not an operational risk it could better be described as a strategic risk. It is argued that the advanced measurement approach is not viable in terms of costs and benefits and is likely to distract financial institutions from the real task of managing operational risk. All businesses strive for optimization by refining their operational. The operational risk management framework should include identification, measurement, monitoring, reporting, control and mitigation frameworks for operational risk.
This positive definition, adopted by the european solvency ii directive for insurers, is a variation from that adopted in the basel ii regulations for. The element positive reputation has hitherto not been used in the literature. Aug 25, 2006 the following pages offer nine indepth contributions from a wide spectrum of perspectives. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. This approach to reputation risk enables fsis to measure brand. Reputational risk, often called reputation risk, is the potential loss to financial capital, social capital andor market share resulting from damage to a firms reputation. Reputational risk an overview sciencedirect topics. Introduction over the last years, we have seen a growing concern for reputation management when facing legal proceedings. Operational risks and reputation risks are now part of managements focus in examining the total enterprise risk. It can be the most important quantitative risk at the end of the day, but there are.
The existence of the online publication or soft documents of the operational risk management. While we acknowledge that some believe in measuring reputation to identify gaps, we assert that these measurement driven techniques may not source all of the threats to reputation hidden deep within a companys organization and processes. Measuring reputation and reputation risk, is however, a difficult task, in part because of the many differing definitions of reputation and reputational risk. Calculating elusive reputational risk a task for a dartboard. Calculating elusive reputational risk a task for a. This definition includes legal risk, but excludes strategic and reputational risk 1 p. This is often measured in lost revenue, increased operating. A strong operational focus is vital to the management of reputation risk. Gatzert and schmit, 2016, thus hav ing various sources.
Stressed periods are modelled by calculating valueat risk using a lossdistributionscenario approach, as for operational risk capital. Applying the methodology to operational risk events in the financial services industry, we observed the following key results. Nov 10, 2014 this paper explores the implications of reputational risk for small, medium, and large size businesses as well as the insurance and risk management solutions designed to help them. Further, risks may have an impact on the reputation of the organi zation or on its status. If companies engage in any measurement at all it is largely based on surveys or focus groups which make it difficult to obtain enough reliable data for a proper quantitative. There are a number of methodologies to choose from when modeling operational risk, each with its advantages and target applications. Walking around a definition reputation risk can be awkward to characterize. The basel committee proposes to look primarily to the type of relationship to the related entity, as, for. Operational risk is the risk of losses resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems or from external events. A great reputation can get you through a problem, points out davia temin. A reputation risk that is not properly managed can quickly escalate into a major strategic crisis. More than half the events tested had a reputation risk impact. Three steps toward managing reputational risk risk. The methodology to manage and measure operational risk.
Reallife case studies within an operational risk framework one important strategy for managing risk is to apply the lessons learned from the experience of others. Learning objectives operational risk data measuring operational risk loss events key risk indicators subjective risk assessments top down approaches bottomup approaches managing operational risk developing an appropriate risk management environment risk identification, assessment, monitoring and control management of. What reputation risk is a top strategic business risk, being a key business challenge. Operational risk represents the next stage in improving shareholder value, by. This includes legal risk, but excludes strategic and reputational risk.
Reputational risk is not considered in most risk management frameworks to be a primary risk. Banks have some focus on self assessments in that regard. The paper also presents two tools developed by the cra that help tax administrations actively protect against significant sources of reputational risk. However, reputation risk management, authenticated for stakeholders through thirdparty attestations and insurances, is powerful marketing. We measure reputational losses by examining a firms stock price reaction to the. A practitioners guide maps out the process of risk assessment and mitigation undertaken by risk managers at unicredit group in response to the requirements of the basel ii accord. One way in which it can be measured is through changes in stock prices, which are well placed to capture the many indirect effects of reputation damage. Reputational risk risk that arises if our shareholder value including earnings and capital is adversely affected by any negative.
Jul 04, 2019 the scholarship on reputational risk management in banks is still limited in size. It is increasingly common for litigations to pose a severe threat to the reputation of a company andor its. Coso erm framework are provided on the coso website and there is a free download of th. Reputational risk represents a more elusive risk category with respect to market, credit and operational risk, because of the difficulty in quantifying its effects and above all in understanding of the mechanisms that generate it. Modelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given situation. Operational and reputational risk in the european banking. Corporate reputation, reputational measurement matrix, reputational risk, kyc, retail bank. The basel committee proposes to look primarily to the type of. It is the first study which develops a holistic approach to measure and manage reputation risk to be implemented in banks in practice. Operational risk can broadly be defined as the risk of direct or indirect losses or damaged reputation due to failure attributable to technology, employees, processes, procedures or physical arrangements, including external events and legal risks. Pdf managing reputational risk from theory to practice.
An example of the steps that can be used to approach a comprehensive risk framework includes. Reputational risk remains one of the more elusive risks because of the. Operational risk is the risk of a change in value caused by the fact that actual losses, incurred for inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems, or from external events including legal risk, differ from the expected losses. Expert at the process required to comply with the sarbanesoxley act. Identification and management of stepin risk bank for international. Aug 11, 2017 the management of reputation risk is challenging, as it is generally considered as a risk of risks see, e. Identification of stakeholders for the following areas i. Aaron passman, how kristen christian came to launch bank transfer day. Linking the identification and assessment of reputational risk to the instruments used for operational risk can be. Established the internal audit function for a newly public company. Approaches to measuring, limiting and managing risks. While financial and operational risk can now be largely quantified, this is not the case for reputational risk.
Measuring reputation and reputation risk, is however, a difficult task, in part because of the many. Reputational risk is not a new concept, but the efforts to manage it as a selfstanding type of risk, rather than within an operational risk framework, are quite recent. Operational and reputational risk in the european banking industry. Measuring operational and reputational risk wiley online. We therefore use the federal reserve systems regulatory definition as our definition of reputational risk. Responsibility for reputation risk resides with the highest levels of the organization board and chow. Identify, measure, and mitigate the risk while building, and maintaining a solid reputation is important for all types of organizations, it is especially important. Awareness, determinants, and value of reputation risk. Jun 07, 2016 pdf download measuring operational and reputational risk. Reputational risk management in financial institutions.
The ibm first risk case studies database is designed to assist risk professionals with their analysis of tail and other loss events by providing reallife case studies that include key. Based on extensive applied research on operational risk models using real bank datasets, it offers a wide range of various testing models and fitting techniques for. For some people, it is a specific risk with clear drivers and tangible business consequences, even if these are hard to quantify. Consequently, reputational risk is arguably the worst type of risk a financial institution is exposed to. Reputation and reputational risk management springerlink. Therefore the board must be fully engaged in an integrated reputation risk strategy that is aware of, and. For others, it is a risk of risks that does not exist on a standalone basis. Nonetheless, the term reputational risk is used in this discussion paper to simply describe the risk of damage to reputation. Although it is called out as a separate category, reputation risk events are. International convergence of capital measurement and capital. Nor do they assign responsibility to a dedicated individual to manage the risk. Ijfs free fulltext operational risk management in financial.
Managing reputational risk measuring operational and. Without a supporting culture and controls imposed from the top, an organisation is susceptible to embarrassing control breakdowns, which could tarnish its reputation. One of the greatest challenges faced by the group was the generic definition of operational risk and the need for flexibility on a businesslevel to integrate the. Our analysis deals with 154 events coming from the first database of opvantage. Within our risk management process, we define reputational risk as the risk of possible damage to our brand and reputation, and the associated risk to earnings, capital or liquidity, arising from any association, action or inaction which could be perceived by stakeholders to be inappropriate, unethical or inconsistent with dbs values and beliefs. All businesses strive for optimization by refining their operational processes.
If the firms market value declines by more than the announced loss amount, this is interpreted as a reputational loss. Oct 02, 20 reputational risk is the top concern for senior executives, according to a new global survey of more than 300 major companies from deloitte. The elements comprising reputation risk differ depending on the. The need for an upfront capital requirement to protect against future potential reputational risk should be limited to those relationships where the risk that a bank will stepin has been clearly identified and quantified. The current study is the result of a survey of operational risk literature based on the. The current study is the result of a survey of operational risk. Organisations tend to claim that reputation risk is covered adequately through existing operational and strategic risk reporting procedures. Of these, credit risk and operational risk are the most important at small and mediumsized institutions in the united states. The methodology to manage and measure operational risk has been. Read pdf measuring operational and reputational risk.
How to avoid the corporate pitfalls of reputational risk. Henry ristuccia, global leader, governance, risk and compliance services, deloitte touche tohmatsu limited, discusses why reputational risk requires a fundamentally different approach from traditional risk management practices and steps organizations can. Measuring the cost of reputation risk is difficult, in part because it can arise as a secondary consequence of other risks. We measure reputational losses by examining a firms stock price reaction to the announcement of a major operational loss event. While operational risk has been receiving significant attention by regulators for more than a decade, incidents such as the exceptional loss at societe generale of almost five billion euro in 2008 caused by the trader jerome kerviel once more spurred the interest paid to operational risk by regulators, supervisors, bank executives, and the public. The purpose of this document is to elaborate an effective approach of managing reputational risks in banks. When an event had a reputation risk impact, the total losses were on average almost double the announced losses. The 10 keys we explore herein address the nuts and bolts of managing reputation risk. How to apply operational risk theory to reallife banking data modelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given situation, according to the type of risk an organization is facing. The leverage ratio is a measure of tier 1 capital as a percentage of exposure as.
The performanceexpectation link forms the basis of the method used to link reputation measurement with sales, and is reflected in the definitions in table 1. Based on extensive applied research on operational risk models using real bank datasets, it offers a wide range of various testing models and fitting techniques for financial. Effective management of reputational risk should be based on systematic identification and assessment of material risk. Operational risk risk arising from inadequate internal processes, people or systems, as well as external events. Deutsche bank annual report 2016 reputational risk.
1096 871 291 998 472 909 1228 980 642 644 1033 918 1042 1506 1104 105 599 155 1331 21 1518 711 82 711 1105 1083 1361 485 344 986 520 405 532 224 1152 577 965 1271